Principle Questions - - Question 16

Psychologists today recognize childhood as a separate stage of life which can only be understood in its own terms, an...

tlrz63 May 9, 2018

Help?

Could you help explain this one to me? I'm lost.

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

smilde11 May 16, 2018

@Trevor

I saw it like this Childhood is a separate stage of life (SSOL) that can only be understood in its own terms (UOT).

SSOL ==> UOT
not UOT ==> not SSOL

It then says how society treats old age as a separate stage of life and concludes that it should have its own field of psychology, or understood in its own terms. That's what answer choice (D) does. Or at least how I ended up choosing (D).

Anita May 16, 2018

The crux of this argument relies on: "But old age is ...fundamentally different... [as proven by] the organization of modern social & economic life." The speaker doesn't tell us why this is how we can tell they're fundamentally different, so a principle that supported that would help. It tells us that that childhood is understood as a separate state of life and treated differently. Therefore, old age should be seen as a separate stage of life and treated differently.

D does that. It tells us that if two distinct times of life are treated as fundamentally different, they can only be understood in their own distinct psychology.

Does that help @tlrz63?