Errors in Reasoning Questions - - Question 85

Those who support the continued reading and performance of Shakespeare's plays maintain that in England appreciation ...

yael July 29, 2018

Why not B?

Can you please explain why the answer is E? B seemed pretty relevant since in the last sentences it talks about the aesthetic aspect of the books

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Christopher July 29, 2018

@yael, the issue with (B) is that the rest of the question is not making an argument about aesthetics but rather about the value of continuing to read and study Shakespeare's work. The original argument is that Shakespeare has always been appreciated by people of varied socio-economic standing, and the final couple of lines about the aesthetic aspects of the books is used counter the argument by claiming that only the rich could afford such books.

So the error in the argument is not that the author is using confusing a socio-economic argument with aesthetics but rather that the author is ignoring another possible explanation for the data. It's possibly that only rich people could afford the books of Shakespeare, but that doesn't mean that poorer people couldn't appreciate Shakespeare through live performance, etc.

Does that help?

yael July 29, 2018

Yes, thank you so much