Flawed Parallel Reasoning Questions - - Question 17

On average, city bus drivers who are using the new computerized fare collection system have a much better on time rec...

LizD August 8, 2018

Clearification please

Could someone explain why C is correct rather than B? Thank you.

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Anita August 9, 2018

@LizD What we're looking for is this pattern:
Xs are on average bigger/better/etc. than Ys
Z is the biggest/best/etc.
Z is an X

This is a flawed argument since the generality does not necessarily apply to individuals.

B mixes this up a bit by saying
Xs are bigger/better/etc. than Ys
Z is a X
Z is bigger/better/etc.

See how that's reversed?

C, on the other hand, goes with:
Xs are bigger/better/etc than Ys
Z is big/better/etc
Z is an X

See how that's the same?