Sufficient & Necessary Questions - - Question 9

If a society encourages freedom of thought and expression, then, during the time when it does so, creativity will flo...

Logan-Frye February 27, 2019

First Premise???

how is the first sentence / premise not a compound (and) statement? Thought & Expression

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Ravi March 1, 2019

@Logan-Frye,

Great question.

The first sentence says, "If a society encourages freedom of thought
and expression, then, during the time when it does so, creativity will
flourish in that society."

The first sentence can be diagrammed as

EFTE - >CF
/CF - >/EFTE

The reason is because the middle part of the sentence, "then, during
the time when it does so," is completely redundant. The first part of
the sentence already defined the parameters of the conditional, so the
second part of the statement is just telling us that we're in those
parameters. It's like saying

EFTE - ->CF
EFTE

Therefore, CF

In fact, the middle part of the sentence could be removed with no loss
of meaning. It's redundant and is put there to confuse you. However,
when we see that it's just restating the sufficient condition, we see
that this convoluted sentence is just a plain-old conditional
statement.

Does that make sense? Let us know if you have any questions!

Logan-Frye March 6, 2019

For the argument completion drills...are you able to combine the contrapositive of one S&N condition to another non-contrapositive S&N condition to come to a conclusion? In other words, if you use one contrapositive S&N condition, are you then only able to use contrapositive S&N conditions for the other premises? Hope this makes sense!

Logan-Frye March 6, 2019

Adding onto my last post...I'm assuming contrapositive S&N conditions can be combined with non-contrapositive S&N conditions since contrapositive and non-contrapositive conditions are both valid??

Jacob-R March 7, 2019

Absolutely, and doing just that is crucial - the LSAT writers try to get you to link up lots of different parts of a logical chain, sometimes using contrapositive and non-contrapositive alike.

Logan-Frye April 16, 2019

what do you suggest when you don't know a word in a lsat question? skip it? or try your best without knowing the meaning?