Weaken Questions - - Question 20

Court records from medieval France show that in the years 1300 to 1400 the number of people arrested in the French re...

Julie-V July 15, 2019

Incorrect Answer Explainations

Hello! I chose the right answer but was wondering if I could get a breakdown as to why B-E can be eliminated. Thank you in advance!

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

shunhe January 6, 2020

Hi @Julie-V,

Thanks for the question. Notice that any correct answer here is going to somehow change the way we interpret the data or cast doubt on the data somehow, since this is the evidence for the author's argument.

(B) is incorrect because it actually strengthens the argument. (B) provides another documented source suggesting that there were high levels of interpersonal violence.

(C) is incorrect because it's not really relevant, since it doesn't change anything about how we view the data at all.

(D) is incorrect because it's also irrelevant, since the definition of "violent interpersonal crimes" explicitly excludes those committed during times of war.

(E) is incorrect because it's irrelevant, since we're told explicitly in the prompt that the number of people arrested increased by a percentage (as opposed to an increase in the percentage of people), so even if the total population went down, the total number of violent interpersonal crimes still went up. Hope this helps!