Daily Drills 1 - Section 1 - Question 2

Select the answer choice that correctly diagrams the following Sufficient & Necessary statement: All Labrador ret...

dianaaguirre November 11, 2019

Confused

Why can't the answer be D?

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

SamA November 11, 2019

Hello @dianaaguirre,

Good question! It is very important to understand this both for logic games and logical reasoning.

"All Labrador retrievers bark a great deal." If it's a Labrador, it's going to bark a great deal. No exceptions.
L - - - - - - - - - - -> BGD

From this, we can create a contrapositive. If it doesn't bark a great deal, then it is not a labrador.
not BGD - - - - - - - - - > not L
This is why A is the correct answer.

Let's look at D. Can we say, "If it's not a Labrador, then it doesn't bark a great deal?" No. This is not a valid conclusion. What about Bernese Mountain Dogs? Yorkipoos? Rat Terriers? These dogs could all bark a great deal. If the passage said, "only Labrador Retrievers bark a great deal," then D would be correct. However, we only have enough information to make a conclusion about Labradors, so we cannot conclude D.