Daily Drills 1 - Section 1 - Question 2

Select the answer choice that correctly diagrams the following Sufficient & Necessary statement: All Labrador ret...

ccj65 November 14, 2019

confused

I dont understand why this is the answer?

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

SamA November 14, 2019

Maybe I can explain it.

We are given a statement: "All labrador retrievers bark a great deal." In order to identify sufficient and necessary conditions, sometimes it helps to rephrase it as an if/then statement.

If it is a labrador, then it barks a great deal.
L - - - - - - - -> BGD
suf nec

This is how that statement is diagrammed. However, this is not listed among our answer choices. Fortunately, we can create a contrapositive, which carries the exact same logic. When the necessary condition fails, then so does the sufficient condition. From this we make the contrapositive.

If it does not bark a great deal, then what can we conclude? That it is not a labrador. All labradors bark a great deal, no exceptions.

not BGD - - - - - - - - > not L
suf nec

This is why A is the correct answer.

Kateria February 2, 2022

Okay I understand now so since the first answer we got was not an answer choice we have to create a contrapositive to get the right answer choice.

Ravi February 8, 2022

That's correct, Kateria.