Must Be True Questions - - Question 49

For democracy to survive, it is imperative that the average citizen be able to develop informed opinions about import...

Reina December 3, 2019

S&N statements?

Where are the S&N statements in this? I didn't know to diagram it at first

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Victoria December 3, 2019

Hi @Reina

Thanks for your question! It can definitely be tricky to find S&N statements when the passage does not explicitly use the common S&N terms. I often found it was helpful to rewrite the sentences to use the typical language, making it easier to understand how to diagram them!

For instance, the first sentence could be rewritten as:

If democracy is to survive (DS), then the average citizen must be able to develop informed opinions about important policy issues (DIOP).

DS - > DIOP
Not DIOP - > not DS

Next, the passage tells us that today's society requires that citizens develop informed opinions about many scientific subjects. In other words, if citizens develop informed opinions about policy issues, then these policy issues must include many scientific subjects (SS).

DIOP - > SS
Not SS - > Not DIOP

Finally, we know that, when scientific knowledge advances (SKA), the average citizen becomes increasingly unable to develop informed opinions on many subjects.

SKA - > Not DIOP
DIOP - > Not SKA

We can then use the transitive property to conclude that:

SKA - > not DIOP - > not DS

Or, as scientific knowledge advances, the public is less able to develop informed opinions on important issues and the survival of democracy is threatened. This is directly restated by answer choice (B), making it the correct answer.

Hope this helps! Please let us know if you have any further questions.