Quantifiers Questions - - Question 14

No projects that involve historical restorations were granted building permits this month. Since some of the current ...

Dalaal March 2, 2020

Diagram answer choices

Hi could you please diagram answer choice A and B? I'm having a hard time doing so

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

SamA March 2, 2020

Hello @Dalaal,

First I'll do the stimulus:
SS - - some - - IHR - - - -> no BP

A.
WCH - - - - - -> not TA
Hospitals - - some - - require extra qualifying exam

I would probably stop diagramming here. We cannot conclude that City Hospital is one of the hospitals that would require an extra exam. They just haven't faced this issue yet. I don't see any connections I can make between these premises to draw a conclusion. Answer choice A does not follow the same pattern of reasoning.

B.
NRES - - - - -> not E
ER - - some - - SPT
Conclusion: EN - - some - - E
I am able to diagram these statements individually, but again they do not form a similar chain of reasoning to that of stimulus.