Strengthen with Necessary Premise Questions - - Question 10

Advertisement: Clark brand-name parts are made for cars manufactured in this country. They satisfy all of our governm...

marcofuentes064 March 18, 2020

Answer E

Can you provide further explanation on why E is incorrect? I picked D because it seemed like a less exaggerated answer.

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Annie March 19, 2020

Hi @marcofuentes064,

This question is asking you to pick the answer choices which identifies the assumption buried in the argument. This means you are picking the choice that is necessary for the argument to be true. You can test your answer choice by negating it. If it is the correct answer, and it is negated, the whole argument should fall apart.

Answer (D) is correct because it is required for the argument. We are told that Clark parts are best because they satisfy our government standards. But, we don't know anything about these government standards, other than that they are the "toughest in the world." That still could mean all the standards out there, including our government's, are really poor standards. If that was the case, just having the Clark parts be up to those standards wouldn't mean anything. Therefore, it must be true that the government standards have some effect for the argument to stand.

Answer (E) is incorrect because it is slightly off topic. This argument isn't about parts made in this country, but rather is about Clark parts specifically. Even if the other parts made by Brands B and C are bad, it is still possible that Clark parts are good.