Strengthen with Necessary Premise Questions - - Question 9

Despite improvements in treatment for asthma, the death rate from this disease has doubled during the past decade fro...

Stephanie May 17, 2020

Explanation for answer D

I understand why E is the correct answer, however why would answer D not be correct? Thank you

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

shunhe May 18, 2020

Hi @Stephanie,

Thanks for the question! So let’s take a look at the stimulus first. We’re told that asthma death rates have doubled, with two possible explanations. But the author doesn’t think either of those explanations are satisfactory, and so the author concludes instead that the cause of increased death has to do with the use of bronchial inhalers to relieve symptoms.

Now we’re asked for a necessary assumption in this argument. Let’s take a look at (D) and think: is this absolutely necessary for the argument? If we negate it and the argument still stands, then it’s not necessary, and we can eliminate it. Let’s say that the use of bronchial inhalers doesn’t aggravate these other diseases that frequently occur among other asthma sufferers. Is it still possible that the bronchial inhalers are the cause of increased deaths? Absolutely! And so (D) can’t be a necessary assumption. Also, notice that we’re talking about an increase in the death rate of asthma, so introducing considerations of fatal outcomes that aren’t asthma-related isn’t relevant here. We’re looking at death by asthma, not deaths of people with asthma, and there’s a difference between the two.

Hope this helps! Feel free to ask any other questions that you might have.

Stephanie May 25, 2020

Thank you!

shunhe May 29, 2020

Glad I could help!