December 2000 LSAT
Section 4
Question 5
If Q is more popular than L, then each of the following must be true of the ranking EXCEPT:
Replies
shunhe on September 14, 2020
Hi @BenjaminBA,Thanks for the question! So this question is asking us for what doesn’t have to be true if Q is more popular than L. In other words, this is asking us for something that can be false.
So let’s make Q more popular than L. Well, that means Q is also more popular than S and V. And H, J, and Q are going to be first, second, and third in that order. P also goes after Q. So can V be fourth? No, because V has to be behind H, J, Q, and L.
Hope this helps! Feel free to ask any other questions that you might have.
Langston on September 29, 2020
L could be fifth: H, J, Q, P, L, S, V which does not violate any of our rules.JamesM on December 10, 2020
why in question 8 does the explanation show "L" to be more popular than "S" when that is inherently obvious through the chain? is it just to be thorough with the rules?sbarnes458 on April 7, 2022
@james in question 8 its not its not comparing L and S its saying S is more popular than P NOT saying J is more popular than J( it talks of J being more popular than L) so basically reread the question carefully.