A good manager must understand people and be able to defuse tense situations. But anyone who is able to defuse tense ...

lklop on September 16, 2020

What is the difference between A & C?

Having some trouble between determining A & C here

Replies

Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

juliagutierrez on September 24, 2020

^^ me too, please help explain.

Victoria on October 10, 2020

Hi @lklop and @juliagutierrez,

Happy to help!

We know that "a good manager must understand people and be able to defuse tense situations."

GM --> UP and DTS
Not UP or Not DTS --> Not GM

The passage also tells us that, if you are able to defuse tense situations, you must understand people.

DTS --> UP
Not UP --> Not DTS

The passage concludes that since Ishiko is able to defuse tense situations, she must be a good manager.

The flaw here is that the passage draws a conclusion about the sufficient condition based on the existence of the necessary condition (i.e. improperly reversing our first conditional diagram above).

In this way, the passage mistakenly concludes that qualities that are necessary for being a good manager are also qualities that guarantee being a good manager (i.e. are sufficient).

The conclusion drawn is about being a good manager, not being able to understand people. This is why answer choice (C) is correct over answer choice (A).

Hope this helps! Please let us know if you have any further questions.