Argument Structure Questions - - Question 28
Rene July 26, 2023
I am also sharing the same question, quite literally word for word, as Brian is here. What would I do? I believe the main conclusion is that People's political behavior frequently does not match their rhetoric, but I would like more clarity on how to be definitively sure of this.
Emil-Kunkin July 30, 2023
I agree with your take on the because test, the first iteration makes much more sense. But I disagree about the therefore test. The idea that people elect reps they resent supports the idea that peoples actions don't match their rhetoric. One is a concrete example of a behavior, and the other is a general principle. The concrete example is evidence for the general principle.