The relationship between which one of the following pairs of documents is most analogous to the relationship between ...
Matt12October 31, 2022
The analogy isn't exactly the same
My issue with A was that it says that welders DO meet the UNION's definition of "Technical".
In the analogy, welders are Roma, union is the 5-point definition, and technical is minority.
Passage B, however, says that Roma DO NOT meet the definition of minority, as written by the author of the 5-point definition. Passage B says therefore that since the definition excludes Roma as minorities, there should be a new definition. That is different that saying Roma are defined as minorities.
Reply
Create a free account to read and
take part in forum discussions.
I think you raise a valid point, however, I would argue that the second paragraph of B is a point by point argument that the Roma are minorities. While I agree there is a slight difference (missing the fact that they also fail to meet the legal criterion), it is a close analogy. Ultimately, it is the only one without a clear and undeniable problem, even if there is a small dissimilarity.
