Strengthen with Necessary Premise Questions - - Question 48

Medical research findings are customarily not made public prior to their publication in a medical journal that has ha...

AndrewArabie January 25, 2023

For those stumped by answer choice B

For those stumped by answer choice B, it's important to remember that in general, a correct answer choice on the LSAT will not baldly contradict a stated premise. The argument states (Premise) prepublication peer review is the only way to ensure potentially harmful information does not reach the public that (premise) is ill equipped to judge medical research. So (conclusion) peer reviewed published research in a *medical journal* is necessary before the public can get its hands on the information. At this point your mind should be asking if there is not another option where peer review can take place because you can't contradict: Premise 1: peer review is necessary Premise 2: the public is ill equipped to judge the merits of the research Answer choice (A) gets at our anticipation here because it highlights the assumption that peer review can't take place outside of medical journals whereas (B) is already a stated premise in the argument and its negation would be contradicting the premise. Im not an instructor but this is how I think about this question. If an instructor disagrees, please defer to the expert and disregard this.

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Emil-Kunkin January 26, 2023

I like this analysis! I would just add that my rationale for eliminating B would look a little different, which does not make either of our right or wrong since wrong answers often are wrong for more than one reason.

I would note that since this is a necessary assumption, the author doesn't have to think that the only people who have the knowledge are those who serve on review boards. They only think that the general public as a whole is not informed, that does not exclude the possibility that some small minority of the general public is well informed.