Argument Structure Questions - - Question 10

Henry:  Some scientists explain the dance of honeybees as the means by which honeybees communicate the location of wh...

JohnC September 19, 2023

Who's Claim

I often feel answers like this are misleading. I would have picked B as my correct answer but ruled it out because it did not specify who's general claim it supports. How do I best determine who the answer is talking about in these open-ended answers?

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Emil-Kunkin September 21, 2023

When an answer choice is vague or general you should try to tie it back to the passage. Here, to say that a statement is used to support a general claim is to say that the statement in question supports some other proposition. Here it supports the proposition that animals have several ways of accomplishing tasks.

However it doesn't really matter which proposition it supports. The answer choice is just saying that it supports a general claim: if we can show that the statement in question does indeed support a general claim, then b is correct regardless of whose claim it supports.

JohnC September 25, 2023

Thank you, of all the question types the open ended ones trip me up the most.