Sally: I cannot study at a university where there is an alcohol problem, so unless something is done about the alcoho...
hassay18August 3, 2024
The Explanation for C
I got C right because it is true that Y undermines S's argument by pointing out that alcohol problems occur even at universities where there are no fraternities. I thought that in saying that, Y does address S's point because S says in schools where there are no frats, there is no alcohol and Y directly addresses her point by saying that all schools - frat or not - have an alcohol problem. So I'm confused as to why the explanation is saying that she isn't addressing S's point at all.
Reply
Create a free account to read and
take part in forum discussions.
S never says that there is no alcohol problem in schools with no frats. She implicitly assumes this, or a weaker version of it, but she never actually says it. Y directly addresses the point yes, but S never actually made the point that Y addresses.
