More Solitary Passages Questions - - Question 19

The author of the passage suggests that in English law a substantive interpretation of a legal rule might be warrante...

hassay18 August 10, 2024

Confused

I picked the right answer (C) but was very confused between C and E. Why is E wrong? What does E even mean?

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Emil-Kunkin August 11, 2024

E is extremely poorly worded! My understanding is that E is effectively the opposite of C. That is, c is saying that the supposed legal rule may not actually be a legal rule, but E is saying that the rule in question has been consistently upheld by higher courts. That is, I would read E as saying that higher courts (and the use of the term superior is odd here, since that could mean different things in different contexts) have ruled in a constant manor as to the validity or application of the rule in question. Thus, there is not uncertainty as to the rules legality or application.

Lui October 7 at 12:30AM

how is D wrong?