Daily Drills 12 - Section 12 - Question 3

P: B → XP: M–some–BC: ?

karen9526 May 18, 2016

Explanation

Could you explain how we got the M-some-X?

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Mehran May 20, 2016

@karen9526 of course!

To make a valid deduction with a Quantifier Statement and a Sufficient & Necessary statement, the variable the statements have in common must be the sufficient condition in the Sufficient & Necessary condition.

Our two premises here are:

P: B âž¡ X

P: M-some-B

What variable do these share in common? B.

Is B the sufficient condition? Yes! So we can combine these statements to make a valid deduction as follows:

M-some-B âž¡ X

To conclude:

M-some-X

This must be true. If some Ms are Bs, this means at least one M is a B.

And since every B is an X, we know that at least one M is also an X.

Hope this helps! For a more in-depth review of these concepts, check out our lesson on Quantifiers.

karen9526 May 22, 2016

That makes much more sense, thanks a ton!