Strengthen with Necessary Premise Questions - - Question 48

Medical research findings are customarily not made public prior to their publication in a medical journal that has ha...

Julie-V July 22, 2019

(B)

Hi LSAT Max, Can you explain choice (B) and why it's incorrect. Thanks!

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Ravi July 23, 2019

@Julie-V,

Happy to help. Let's look at (A) and (B).

This question is a strengthen with a necessary
premise question, so if the negation of an answer choice wrecks the
argument, then we know that it's the correct answer choice.

(B) says, "anyone who does not serve on a medical review panel does
not have the necessary knowledge and expertise to evaluate medical
research findings"

(B)'s negation is, "Anyone who does not serve on a medical review
panel still might have the necessary knowledge and expertise to
evaluate medical research findings."

(B)'s negation does not wreck the argument. The premises of the
argument already inform us that a peer review panel is necessary in
order to evaluate the findings. However, why it's needed (whether it's
expertise, knowledge, or some other reason) is something that doesn't
matter for us. Thus, (B) is out.

(A) says, "unless medical research findings are brought to peer review
by a medical journal, peer review will not occur"

(A)'s negation is, "Peer review of medical research findings does not
require publication in a medical journal."

(A) does a great job in capturing the necessary assumption that the
conclusion is jumping toward (peer review needs a medical journal).
However, if peer-reviewed findings could be published in other places
(which is what the negation says), then the argument falls apart,
which tells us that (A) is the correct answer choice.

Does this make sense? Let us know if you have any more questions!