Point at Issue Questions - - Question 11

Harris: Currently, hybrid animals are not protected by international endangered species regulations. But new techniqu...

Julie-V August 19, 2019

Stimulus Breakdown

Hi LSAT Max, I was wondering if you could break down the argument and explain why (D) would be correct as well as why (B) can be eliminated. Thanks!

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Ravi August 19, 2019

@Julie-V,

Let's look at (B) and (D) as well as the argument.

We know that Harris is mad about the present state of
endangered-species laws. Although they may protect traditional
species, they don't currently protect hybrid animals that are the
mixture of two species. Harris concludes that we should change these
laws to include the protection of hybrid animals.

Vogel, on the other hand, disagrees. She says that if the independent
source species of the hybrid are protected, then we can simply breed
more hybrids through using the two independent species if the hybrids
diet out and get close to extinction.

We're looking for a point at issue (disagreement) between Harris and
Vogel. The correct answer choice will be supported by one of the
speakers and will go against what the other speaker is saying. With
this argument, we know that Harris and Vogel have opposing
conclusions. Harris thinks that we should change the laws to add
protection for hybrids, whereas Vogel doesn't think that hybrids need
protection.

(B) says, "whether there are some species that are currently
considered endangered that are not in fact in any danger"

Vogel makes the suggestion that some hybrids might not be endangered,
but we can infer from the stimulus that a hybrid isn't considered a
species. Additionally, Harris doesn't have an opinion on (B), so we
can get rid of it.

(D) says, "whether there are some hybrids that ought to be protected
by endangered-species regulations"

Harris agrees with (D), and provides the red wolf as an example. Vogel
states that it doesn't make sense to make laws to protect hybrids, so
they disagree on (D). Thus, (D) is the correct answer choice.

Does this make sense? Let us know if you have any other questions!