Weaken Questions - - Question 46

A large group of hyperactive children whose regular diets included food containing large amounts of additives was obs...

Meredith August 29, 2019

Why is D incorrect?

What aspect of D makes it incorrect?

Reply
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Ravi August 29, 2019

@Meredith,

Let's look at (D).

(D) says, "there is no evidence that the behavior of some of the
children was unaffected by additives"

The problem with (D) is that the conclusion could still be true even
if none of the children were unaffected by additives, so the argument
does not need to provide evidence that some children were unaffected.
Thus, we can get rid of (D).

(B) says, "there is no way to know what changes would have occurred
without the change of diet, since only children who changed to a low
additive diet were studied"

With (B), having a control group is one possible way to reduce
potential alternative causes. Perhaps the additives didn't have
anything to do with the change in behavior and such behavior naturally
changes over time. In order to eliminate this possibility, we would
need to study a group of children whose diet was not changed as well.
Thus, (B) is the correct answer choice.

Does this make sense? Let us know if you have any other questions!