# At a gathering at which bankers, athletes, and lawyers are present, all of the bankers are athletes and none of the l...

Zaviea-Gaynor on December 13, 2018

Answer choice

Why is it C instead of E?

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Jacob-R on December 13, 2018

Iâ€™m happy to help. As always, letâ€™s start with the question stem. It is a must be true question. In order to know what must be true, we have to understand the argument:

If B, A, and L ==>

B -> A (contrapositive not A -> not B)
AND
L -> not B (contrapositive B -> not L)

Remember, we know that bankers, athletes, and lawyers are all present. So there will be at least one banker, and we know from rule 1 that that banker is also an athlete. And we know from the contrapositive of rule 2 that that banker is not a lawyer. So at least one athlete is not a lawyer, which is answer C.

E is incorrect because we could hypothetically have a lawyer who is an athlete and that wouldnâ€™t violate any of the rules or contrapositive, so â€œnone of the lawyers are athletesâ€ need not be true.

I hope that helps! Please let us know if you have further questions.

Zaviea-Gaynor on January 9, 2019

How can i improve my score of 23 point quickly?