Free LSAT Practice
LSAT Practice Test
LSAT Practice Test Videos
eBook: The Road to 180
Law School Top 100
LSAT Test Proctor
LSAT Logic Games
Apple App Store
Digital LSAT Simulator
Fee Waiver Scholarship
LSAT Test Dates
LSAT Message Board
December 2014 LSAT
Journalist: It is unethical for journalists to lie-to say something untrue with the purpose of deceiving the listener...
on January 16, 2019
Why not E? It seemed to work in my eyes...
on February 16, 2019
Letâ€™s take a look at Answer E. Answer E says the journalist is arguing by â€œclarifying and defending a moral principle by comparing a case in which it applies to one in which it does not apply.â€
In this case, the moral principle is that â€œit is unethical for journalists to lie.â€ While the journalist can be said to be â€œclarifyingâ€ this moral principle, they are not so much â€œdefendingâ€ it. In order to defend a moral principle, the journalist would need to be responding to those who call it into question. That is not the case here. The journalist is not defending this idea against those who say that journalists SHOULD be able to lie.
Turning to the second half of Answer E, is the journalist really â€œcomparing a case in which it applies to one in which it does not apply"? Is the journalist saying that the principle of lying being unethical doesnâ€™t apply when a journalist withholds information? I think the journalist would say this principle still applies in this scenario. Indeed, the principle should guide journalists' behavior at all times. Instead, the journalist is saying that the principle still applies, only that withholding information is not truly lying.
For these reasons, Answer E does not accurately express how the journalist is making their argument. The correct answer, Answer A, does a better job at expressing how the journalist draws distinctions between two cases (actively encouraging false belief vs. withholding information) in order to show that these two activities cannot both be considered â€œlyingâ€ by journalists.
I hope this helps. Please reach out with other questions!
Posting to the forum is only allowed for members with active accounts.