There is evidence to suggest that our cave–dwelling ancestors polished many of their flints to a degree far surpassin...

Ava on April 16 at 02:39AM

Why is B incorrect?

If the caves in high the flints were found are u adorned by cave paintings, then this would weaken the conclusion that early humans had an aesthetic sense. It seems that D, the correct answer, is unrelated to the argument at hand...

1 Reply

Ravi on April 16 at 07:03PM

@shafieiava,

Happy to help.

(B) says, "The caves in which the highly polished flints were found
are unadorned by cave paintings."

The problem with (B) is that a dearth of cave paintings does not
necessarily mean that cave dwellers didn't care at all about
aesthetics. It's possible that the polished flints provided the cave
dwellers with the amount of beauty they wanted. As a result, we can
get rid of this choice.

(D) says, "Flints were often used by early humans for everyday chores
other than hunting."

(D) tells us that the flints are used for things other than simply
hunting. And it's possible that one of those chores could be the
reason that the flints were polished, just as it's possible that they
could've been polished for aesthetic purposes. (D) casts doubt on the
conclusion of the argument by introducing an alternative explanation,
so it weakens the argument and is the right answer.

Does this answer your question? Let us know if you have any other questions!