Many symptoms of mental illnesses are affected by organic factors such as a deficiency in a compound in the brain. Wh...

Serra on May 22 at 04:08PM

Explanation

Could we please have a full explanation for this question? Thank You!

3 Replies

Ravi on May 22 at 07:20PM

@msaber,

Happy to help!

The stimulus is basically telling us that there are some symptoms of
mental illness that are affected by various organic factors. However,
in looking around the globe, there's a large variation in the
incidences of these symptoms. Because of this, the argument concludes
that the organic factors that are actually affecting people vary
throughout the world.

So we know that symptoms vary a lot from culture to culture. While
it's true that organic factors varying could be the reason for this,
it's possible that they're not the reason. Perhaps some culture simply
reveals certain things more than others do. The argument is ignoring
the fact that it's possible that the mental illness symptom incidences
are caused by things that aren't organic.

(C) says, "fails to consider the possibility that cultural factors
significantly affect how mental illnesses manifest themselves in
symptoms"

(C) describes a type of non-organic variable that might be causing the
variation in mental illness symptoms, and this is something that the
argument ignores. This is why (C) is the correct answer.

Hope this helps—let us know if you have any more questions!

Serra on May 24 at 02:27AM

This is great, Ravi! Thank you :)

Ravi on May 24 at 04:12PM

@msaber, you're welcome! :)