Naturalist: Different nonhuman primate species axhibit many contrasts in behavior. If a zookeeper leaves a screwdrive...

Claire on May 23 at 07:12PM

Question

How do I distinguish between C and E? Don't they both describe contrasts in behavior?

1 Reply

Victoria on May 24 at 09:27PM

Hello @claire_crites,

Both C and E describe contrasts in behaviour; however, E requires us to make assumptions which cannot be strongly asserted based on the information provided.

E is incorrect because we cannot be sure whether the chimpanzees understand tool use. While chimpanzees and orangutans exhibit different behaviours when presented with a tool, we cannot then extrapolate from these behaviours to determine whether the primates understand tool use or not.

C is more strongly supported by the naturalist's statements as the orangutans pretend to ignore the tool when the zookeeper is around and then use it when the zookeeper leaves. This act of pretending to ignore the tool means that at least some nonhuman primates are capable of deception.

Hope this is helpful! Please let us know if you have any further questions.