Which one of the following, if substituted for the constraint that Wellspring and Zircon each perform in an earlier s...

SarahA on June 3, 2019

Why is E incorrect?

Could someone please explain why answer choice E is incorrect and why answer choice A is correct-and how they are different?

Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Ravi on June 3, 2019


Happy to help. Let's look at (E) and (A).

In looking at our original rules, we have

V - Z - X and W - X

U must be in 4/5/6

U having to be in 4/5/6 means that V must be in 1/2/3 because V has to
come before Z and X and if V were in 4, then we wouldn't have enough
room for Z, X, and U.

V must be in 1/2/3

Y must be in 1/2/3

Y having to be in 1/2/3 means that X has to go in 5/6 because V, Z,
and W come before it and if X were in 4, then we wouldn't have enough
room for V, Z, W, and Y.

X 5/6

The question tells us we are subbing a new rule for the rule that W
and Z are before X.

(E) says X performs in either slot 5 or 6.

The problem with (E) is that if we substituted this rule in, we could
have W and X swapping places in 5 and 6, whereas in the old world W
had to come before X.

With (E), we could have a game board that showed


This board wouldn't be possible with our original rules, so (E) is out.

(A) says only U can perform in a later slot than X.

This means V, Z, W, and Y have to go before X and U is the only piece
that can go after.

This restores the W before X from our original rules. It also restores
Z going before X. V was already before X, so that stays the same. And
Y before X? Yes, that was true in the original rules because we know
that Y had to go in 1/2/3 and X was in 5/6, so (A) is a perfect rule
substitution. In our original rules, U, having the ability to go in
4/5/6 was the only piece that could go after X in 5/6.

Hope this helps. Let us know if you have any more questions!