Which one of the following could be the assignment of departments to floors?

hannahnaylor5 on September 5, 2019

Why could the set up not be 1-5-1?

I might have missed something in the explanation. I came up with a scenario that looked like: Top: H Middle: F S P T I Bottom: L I don't see why this couldn't be an option? Could you please explain further? Thank you!

Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Irina on September 5, 2019


The reason the option in your question is impossible because each floor can accommodate at most four departments, hence a scenario with five departments on one floor would violate the rules.

Let's quickly review the setup for this game:

A law firm has seven department - F H I L P S T. The firm occupies a building with three floors - bottom, middle, top. Each floor can accommodate up to four departments, and no department is on more than one floor.

The following rules apply:

(1) Probate must be on the same floor as tax law.

P & T

(2) Health law must be on the floor immediately above injury law.

H > T

We can also infer that H cannot be on the bottom floor and injury law cannot be on the top floor.

T: ~I
B: ~ H

HI combination thus must either be on top and middle floors respectively or middle and bottom floors.

T: H
M: I


M: H
B: I

(3) Labor law must occupy the entire floor by itself.

This tells us that it could never be on the middle floor because either H or I must always be on the middle floor. Let's consider both scenarios:'

T: H
M: I
B: L

In this scenario, P &T could go on the top or middle floor.

T: L
M: H
B: I

In this scenario, P & T could go on the middle or bottom floor.

The remaining two departments could either both go with H/I or one could go with HPT/ IPT combination and one could go with H/I.

Let me know if you have any further questions.