Council chair: The traditional code of parliamentary procedure contains a large number of obscure, unnecessary rules,...

sophi98 on October 5, 2019

Explanation

Hi, can someone please explain why B is wrong?

Replies

Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

BenMingov on October 7, 2019

Hi Sophi98, thanks for the question!

The argument describes problems in their parliamentary procedure and concludes that it must adopt an alternate code, because it worked well somewhere else.

We need to weaken this claim.

Answer choice B, by saying that the alternate code is sometimes used to mix up opponents, does not tell us that the alternate code will not be successful. Perhaps there is a way to obscure your opponent's understanding of procedures in every parliamentary code.

Hope this helps!

cjahangiri on December 27, 2019

This makes sense, but could you please explain how C is the best answer? Thanks!

ChristianJM on April 1, 2020

Ya why is c right

lxnxrd19 on March 22, 2021

why is E wrong? please?

liwenong28 on May 28, 2021

Im not an instructor but let me try to explain why E is wrong.

(E) states that the alternate code contains "few provisions", however in contrast, the stimulus states that the traditional code contains "a large number". Therefore E actually strengthens the conclusion.

I hope this helps!