If the standards committee has a quorum, then the general assembly will begin at 6:00 P.M. today. If the awards commi...

First on November 26 at 04:54AM

WHY NOT B

Why can't B be correct?

1 Reply

Annie on November 26 at 04:51PM

Hi @madisanbryant,

This question asks you to choose the answer choice which "follows logically" from the statements. This is just a fancy way of asking you to find the conclusion which fits with the premises provided. Here's a breakdown:

Premise: If SC quorum - - - then GA at 6.
Premise: If AC quorum - - - then GA at 7.
Conclusion: ??

Answer Choices:
(A) is incorrect. This answer choice assumes that either AC or SC must have a quorum. It's possible that the both don't have a quorum.

(B) is incorrect. Again, this is assuming that either AC or SC must have a quorum. There is nothing in the premises to support this.

(C) is incorrect. This reverses premise 1 which we can't do (with an if/then statement, you can't just reverse the then/if to get a new conclusion). There could be many other reasons for the GA to begin at 6 that we just don't know about.

(D) is incorrect. This is just the opposite of answer choice A and is likewise wrong.

(E) is correct. The GA is a single event, and therefore cannot begin at both 6 and 7 on the same night. If both committees were to have a quorum, it would have to. Therefore, we know that both committees can NOT have a quorum.