June 2017 LSAT
Section 2
Question 25
Substantial economic growth must be preceded by technological innovations that expanding industries incorporate into ...
Reply
shunhe on January 1, 2020
Hi @tomgbean,Unfortunately, your diagramming isn't quite right, which made you eliminate (D) wrongly. I'll diagram it first and then go through (A) and (D). Note that the first sentence reads, "substantial economic growth MUST BE preceded by technological innovations..." The "must" tips us off to the presence of a conditional. Personally, I don't think of it in terms of necessary/sufficient conditions, which can be a bit confusing. Instead, I think of it this way. If economic growth must be preceded by technological innovations, that means that if we have economic growth, then we had technological innovations as well. Otherwise, we wouldn't have the economic growth. And "if X, then Y" is easily translatable into "X - > Y." So here, we would have:
Substantial economic growth - > Preceded by technological innovations
For the second sentence:
Worldwide ban on fossil fuels - > Technological innovations
And from that, we conclude:
Worldwide ban on fossil fuels - > Economic boom
Let's talk about (A) first. Does the argument assume the truth of the conclusion for which it purports to be providing evidence, essentially making a circular argument? No, as the conclusion is that a ban on fossil fuels would be followed by an economic boom, but that isn't one of the two premises we identified. Thus, we can rule out (A).
We can see, however, that (D) is correct after we've diagrammed it correctly. The argument confuses a necessary condition with a sufficient condition. Note that the author wants to conclude the following:
Ban - > Technological innovations - > Economic growth
But because the first sentence of the stimulus actually tells us
Economic growth - > Technological innovations
We can't actually make the logical chain the author fallaciously makes. The author makes this mistake because he believes Technological innovations - > Economic Growth, and (D) is therefore the correct answer. Hope this helps, and feel free to ask any questions of clarification.