Politician: The current crisis in mathematics education must be overcome if we are to remain competitive in the globa...

Ava on February 2 at 02:28AM

Approach

Can someone explain the correct answer here, and how they approached/arrived at that answer? Thanks in advance.

1 Reply

Annie on February 2 at 09:26PM

Hi @shafieiava,

This question calls for diagramming. Here's an outline of the argument:

Remain competitive in economy - -> overcome crisis in math
Overcome crisis in math - - > employ successful teaching methods
Successful teaching methods - -> students study outside class

Now turning to the answer choices:

(A) is incorrect because it reverses the logic. It says that if students study outside - -> then we'll overcome the crisis in math. This combines the premises backwards.

(B) is correct. It diagrams to: overcome crisis in math - -> students study outside class. This simply combines premises 2 and 3 and therefore it follows logically from the premises.

(C) is incorrect because it is irrelevant.

(D) is incorrect. It diagrams to: students study outside class - -> remain competitive in economy. This is the reverse logic of the argument.

(E) is incorrect. The argument tells us that we can only remain competitive if students spend time studying math outside class. This answer choice tells us that we will definitely remain competitive if students spend time studying math outside class. These are not the same thing, and therefore the answer choice can't be inferred from the premises.