Music critic: Some people argue that, unlike certain works of Handel, which set to music familiar religious texts, th...

Henleys on April 14, 2020

Could you please explain?

Had a hard time finding the flaw in this one

Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Skylar on April 15, 2020

@Henleys, happy to help!

The passage says some people argue that Vierne's organ symphonies are not religious music. This is contrasted with Handel's work, which sets familiar religious texts to music and is considered religious music. However, the critic disagrees with this argument, implying that s/he believes Vierne's symphonies are religious music. S/he says that hearing Vierne's symphonies in Notre Dame cathedral demonstrates that they are divinely inspired.

Though subtle, the critic is shifting the meaning of the word "religious." In the beginning of the passage, the critic references religious music as being based on religious texts. At the end, the critic references religious music as being "divinely inspired." Are these the same? No, the first definition has to do with the substance the music was derived from whereas the second definition has more to do with the feeling of the music in a specific setting. This shift suggests that the critic confused different meanings of the word "religious," which makes (B) the correct answer.

Does that make sense? Please let us know if you have any other questions!