Company president: For the management consultant position, we shall interview only those applicants who have worked ...

If C was reversed in that it said a whole to parts situation, where the mistake would be in assuming if it is true of the whole than it is true of the parts comprising the whole, would C than be a stronger answer choice? Since the manager is assuming that because a company is in the top 1% it’s employees are also the top 1%, or would it still be incorrect?