on July 13 at 09:39PM
It seems to me that answer E isn't enough to really weaken the argument. The paragraph says that it can't be Jazz because the improvisation strays too far from the original melody. To me it seems that this argument could care less whether the new Jazz resembles old Jazz more than anything else, if it strays too far from the original melody, then it's not Jazz.
Annie on July 14 at 02:17AM