June 2008 LSAT - Section 1 - Question 22

Which one of the following, if true, would most support the author's contentions concerning the conditions under whic...

lklop June 13, 2021

Why is A wrong?

Seems to strengthen the argument

Replies
Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

maeve August 31, 2023

I have the same question!

maeve August 31, 2023

Oh, maybe because it doesn't explain "the conditions under which groupthink takes place," as the question states!

Emil-Kunkin September 4, 2023

Hi, the authors thesis is that groupthink is enables by cohesive groups. The fact that groupthink happens across industries doesn't really do anything to support or disprove the idea that groupthink is enabled by cohesion. However, the idea that groupthink doesn't happen when there is distrust supports the idea that cohesion enables groupthink.

amoli078@fiu.edu September 5, 2023

can you break down why d is incorrect

Emil-Kunkin September 7, 2023

Hi, I'm not sure how factions would really impact the idea that groupthink is enabled by cohesion. However, if anything, I think it would weaken the authors contention. The author thinks groupthink happens when there is too much cohesion, d shows it also happens with too little cohesion.

Emil-Kunkin September 7, 2023

Hi, I'm not sure how factions would really impact the idea that groupthink is enabled by cohesion. However, if anything, I think it would weaken the authors contention. The author thinks groupthink happens when there is too much cohesion, d shows it also happens with too little cohesion.