October 1994 LSAT
Section 1
Question 18
Emil-Kunkin on May 5, 2023
This is a though one. I would never have described the issue with Erik's argument like A, and I would have absolutely said something along the lines that you did. However, I do think that when responding to an argument that is effectively "X is good so we should do it" you need to show some reason why either X is not good, or why doing X would be bad for some reason like cost or unintended consequences.AndrewArabie on May 6, 2023
Glad to know I'm in good company. I certainly understand the rationale you provided for A. Thank you