October 2004 LSAT Section 4 Question 16

Moralist: Immoral actions are those that harm other people. But since such actions eventually harm those who perform...

Shula on October 23 at 11:36PM

Why is D correct?

Could someone plz explain why D is the correct answer? How would we know that an assumption required is that "Those who, in acting immorally, eventually harm themselves do not intend that harm.?

Create a free account to read and take part in forum discussions.

Already have an account? log in

Emil-Kunkin on October 27 at 09:41PM

The author argues that since hurting others eventually hurts ourselves, those who hurt others must be unaware of the consequences of hurting others. There is a pretty huge flaw here, the author doesn't give us any reason to think they must be unaware. The fact that an action will hurt the actor doesn't prove the actors doesn't know it will hurt them. People act self destructively all the time. Perhaps I know that burning my neighbors shed down will harm me, but I simply detest my neighbor more than I care about myself.

To make any sense, the author must agree that the harm to oneself is not intentional.